Tesla’s European Sales Face a 47% Drop: Analyst Predicts Market Shifts

Tesla’s European sales are projected to plummet by 47% in April 2024, according to prominent financial analyst Gary Black, with a ripple effect potentially reducing the automaker’s global deliveries by 6% through 2025. The alarming forecast, based on weakening demand and intensified competition, casts doubt on Tesla’s dominance in the electric vehicle (EV) sector and sparks scrutiny of its long-term strategy.

Why Tesla’s European Market Is Stalling

Europe, Tesla’s second-largest market after China, accounted for nearly 25% of its global deliveries in 2023. However, recent data suggests a dramatic reversal:

• April 2024 Projections: Sales expected to drop to 12,000 units from 22,700 in April 2023
• Market Share Erosion: Tesla’s EU EV share fell to 12.4% in Q1 2024, down from 18.5% in 2023
• Competitor Growth: BYD, Volkswagen, and Stellantis saw combined sales rise 34% in the same period

“Tesla’s ‘growth at all costs’ approach is hitting a wall in Europe,” says automotive industry analyst Clara Voss. “Local manufacturers are flooding the market with affordable EVs, while Tesla’s aging Model 3 and Y lineup struggles to differentiate.”

The Perfect Storm of Challenges

Multiple factors contribute to Tesla’s declining European performance:

1. Subsidy Reductions: Germany, Tesla’s largest EU market, abruptly ended EV incentives in December 2023, causing a 77% quarterly sales drop for the automaker. France and Norway have similarly scaled back support.

2. Production Bottlenecks: Delays at Gigafactory Berlin due to environmental protests and supply chain issues limited Q1 output to 35,000 vehicles—40% below capacity.

3. Consumer Sentiment Shift: A recent EuroStat survey revealed 58% of potential EV buyers now prioritize “local brands” over Tesla, citing service network concerns and charging compatibility.

What This Means for Tesla’s Future Deliveries

Black’s revised 2025 delivery estimate of 1.8 million vehicles (down from 1.92 million) accounts for cascading effects:

• Inventory Glut: European warehouses reportedly hold 15,000 unsold Teslas as of mid-April
• Price War Fallout: Repeated cuts eroded Tesla’s automotive gross margin to 16.3% in Q1—the lowest since 2020
• Model 3 Refresh Impact: The updated Highland version failed to boost orders as anticipated

“Tesla needs a European-specific vehicle under €30,000 to compete,” argues Matthias Schmidt, publisher of the European Electric Car Report. “Their premium pricing strategy works in the U.S., but Europe demands compact, utilitarian EVs.”

Diverging Views on Recovery Potential

While bears highlight structural issues, Tesla optimists point to potential rebounds:

Bull Case: Gigafactory Berlin’s expansion to 1 million annual units by 2026 could reduce costs and delivery times. The rumored €25,000 “Model 2” might revive mass-market appeal.

Bear Case: Bernstein analysts note Tesla’s European orders declined year-over-year for five consecutive quarters. “Demand erosion appears systemic, not cyclical,” warns senior analyst Toni Sacconaghi.

Strategic Crossroads for Elon Musk’s Empire

The sales slump forces difficult choices:

Option 1: Accelerate new model launches, risking further margin compression
Option 2: Maintain premium positioning, ceding volume to competitors
Option 3: Pursue acquisitions to gain local manufacturing expertise

“Tesla’s next move in Europe will define its trajectory for the decade,” says Voss. “They must either go all-in on localization or accept diminished regional influence.”

The Broader EV Market Implications

Industry observers see Tesla’s struggles as symptomatic of broader trends:

• EU EV sales growth slowed to 11% in Q1 2024 versus 28% in 2023
• Chinese automakers now hold 9.3% of Europe’s EV market, up from 4.7% in 2022
• Legacy automakers leverage hybrid transitions to offset pure EV weaknesses

As the dust settles, Tesla’s response to its European challenges may offer a template for other global EV players navigating maturing markets. Investors and competitors alike await Musk’s next move—will it be retreat, reinvention, or redoubled commitment?

For ongoing coverage of Tesla’s market performance and EV industry trends, subscribe to our weekly automotive insights report.

See more Business Focus Insider Team