As the holiday shopping season commences, Black Friday remains a key indicator of consumer behavior, retailer strategies, and the overall health of the retail industry. This annual sales event, which marks the start of the holiday shopping rush, has evolved over the years. While some retailers manage to secure major victories, others fall behind due to shifting consumer preferences, logistical challenges, and intense competition. In this analysis, we explore which retailers excelled during Black Friday 2024 and which struggled to meet expectations, offering insights into the broader trends shaping the retail landscape.

The Evolution of Black Friday: More Than Just a Shopping Day

Black Friday has traditionally been the biggest shopping day of the year in the U.S., with consumers flocking to brick-and-mortar stores and flocking online for steep discounts. However, the rise of online shopping, the expansion of pre-Black Friday deals, and the shift to e-commerce have significantly altered the event’s landscape. The days of chaotic store crowds are increasingly replaced by digital deals that extend well beyond Friday itself, often spilling into the entire Thanksgiving weekend or even lasting for weeks.

The pandemic accelerated many of these shifts, with online shopping surpassing in-store visits and retailers adapting quickly to digital-first strategies. For 2024, it was evident that companies that could blend physical and online experiences effectively would be the ones to come out on top. Let’s take a closer look at how key players performed this year.

The Winners: Retailers Who Gained Ground in 2024

This year, several companies successfully capitalized on the growing importance of e-commerce, effective marketing strategies, and innovations in customer experience. These retailers emerged as the victors in the Black Friday showdown:

Amazon: Dominating the Digital Marketplace

As expected, Amazon maintained its leadership in the Black Friday rush. The tech giant continues to benefit from its expansive product catalog, competitive prices, and efficient logistics network. Amazon’s Prime Early Access Sale, which took place in October, set the stage for Black Friday by offering early discounts and driving traffic to its platform. On the actual day, Amazon saw a surge in consumer spending, particularly in electronics, home goods, and apparel.

• Innovative Deals: Amazon’s strategy of offering personalized discounts based on previous purchasing history kept consumers engaged and motivated to shop.
• Subscription Services: Prime memberships saw a significant increase, which not only boosted sales but also locked in loyal customers for the long term.
• Prime Video and Devices: In addition to shopping, Amazon leveraged its media platforms like Prime Video to enhance its brand visibility and attract more shoppers.

Walmart: Reinventing the In-Store and Online Experience

Walmart’s hybrid approach of combining in-store and digital shopping paid off handsomely this Black Friday. With massive discounts in electronics, home goods, and toys, the retail giant saw impressive foot traffic in its physical stores, while its website also saw a significant spike in visits. Walmart’s ability to balance both channels—offering curbside pickup and efficient delivery options—enabled it to cater to a wide range of customer preferences.

• Enhanced Shopping Experience: Walmart’s revamped website and app made the shopping experience smoother for users, improving site navigation and checkout options.
• Exclusive In-Store Deals: Special offers available only in-store motivated customers to visit physical locations, leading to an uptick in foot traffic.

Target: A Strong Omnichannel Strategy

Target leveraged its strong omnichannel strategy to perform well during Black Friday 2024. With a focus on competitive pricing and streamlined delivery options, the retailer attracted a significant number of shoppers both online and in-store. Target’s partnerships with popular brands and its focus on offering exclusive, limited-time products also gave it an edge in key categories, including toys, home décor, and electronics.

• Target Circle Rewards: Target’s loyalty program proved highly effective in driving repeat purchases, giving customers exclusive deals and early access to sales.
• Seamless Integration: The company’s ability to integrate curbside pickup, same-day delivery, and in-store shopping created a smooth, flexible shopping experience.

The Strugglers: Retailers Who Fell Behind

Despite the overall success of Black Friday 2024, some retailers struggled to keep pace with consumer expectations or failed to adapt to the evolving retail environment. These companies faced challenges ranging from logistical issues to poor online shopping experiences and a lack of competitive pricing.

Macy’s: A Traditionalist in an Evolving Market

Macy’s, once a dominant player in Black Friday sales, faced significant challenges in 2024. The department store chain failed to draw the same level of foot traffic as in previous years, particularly in the face of aggressive online competition. While the company offered discounts on a variety of items, it was unable to match the speed and convenience of e-commerce giants like Amazon and Walmart.

• Lack of Online Innovation: Macy’s digital platforms were less efficient than those of its competitors, leading to a subpar online shopping experience for customers.
• Challenges in Store Traffic: Macy’s struggled to create compelling in-store events that could lure customers away from the convenience of online shopping.

Kohl’s: Facing Intense Competition

Kohl’s, another staple in the department store industry, experienced slower-than-expected sales this Black Friday. The company’s challenges were linked to its pricing strategy and lack of compelling exclusive deals. Kohl’s often struggles to differentiate itself from competitors like Target and Walmart, who offer similar products at more competitive prices and with better customer service options.

• Overreliance on Discounts: Kohl’s promotions weren’t compelling enough to drive significant foot traffic, especially when compared to the deals available from larger competitors.
• Supply Chain Issues: Stockouts in key categories, including clothing and electronics, frustrated many potential customers.

Key Takeaways: Trends and Implications

The results of Black Friday 2024 offer valuable insights into the evolving retail landscape:

• Omnichannel is King: Retailers that successfully integrated both online and in-store shopping had the most success. The ability to offer options like curbside pickup, same-day delivery, and robust digital platforms is essential for maintaining a competitive edge.
• Consumer Loyalty Programs: Loyalty programs like Amazon Prime, Walmart+, and Target Circle proved to be highly effective in driving repeat business and encouraging customers to return throughout the holiday season.
• Logistics Matter: Efficient delivery systems and the ability to meet customer demands quickly were key factors in the success of top-performing retailers.
• Price Sensitivity: Competitive pricing remains a crucial factor. Retailers that struggled tended to offer less competitive pricing or failed to entice shoppers with enough value.

Conclusion: A New Era of Retail Competition

Black Friday 2024 showcased the continued evolution of the retail industry, highlighting the growing importance of a seamless omnichannel experience, consumer loyalty programs, and competitive pricing. Amazon, Walmart, and Target emerged as clear winners due to their strong digital infrastructure, innovative customer experiences, and ability to adapt to shifting consumer demands. Meanwhile, traditional retailers like Macy’s and Kohl’s struggled to keep up, underscoring the need for ongoing adaptation in a rapidly changing retail environment.

As we move further into the holiday season, the lessons learned from Black Friday will shape how retailers approach the remainder of the year and beyond. With increasing competition and rising consumer expectations, those that fail to innovate risk falling further behind in the retail race.

For more information on how to make the most of your holiday shopping this season, visit Retail Dive.

See more Business Focus Insider Team